"What is ""Normal?"" A Beethovenian Reconsideration of Some of Tovey's Aesthetic Principles"

Donald Francis Tovey’s writings on music continue to have a strong influence on scholarship seventy years after his death. In several of his essays, he mentions “normality” and “freedom” as meaningful aesthetic principles, but when one examines closely his use of these concepts, one discovers seemingly contradictory formulations. On the one hand, Tovey insists that “normality” in music is achieved by the resolution of internal conflicts, and that the process by which this occurs is one of “freedom”—in other words, the process is not formulaic but rather unique to each composition; as Tovey puts it, “an art form grows from within instead of being moulded from without.” On the other hand, his writings demonstrate clearly that he values convention in music, and his notion of “normality” is undoubtedly also informed by the fulfillment of certain expectations cultivated externally; he writes, for instance, that “nothing is more sterilizing than the critical conventions which demand originality as a sine qua non for all artists,” and that “it is stupid to use a convention in a way which shows that you have missed its point, but it is no cleverer to violate a convention because you do not understand it.” Tovey applies his paradoxical conceptions of “normality” and “freedom” to Beethoven’s C-sharp–minor string quartet, Op. 131. In my thesis, I first demonstrate how Tovey’s ideas have informed and continue to influence scholarship on that work. I then probe the extent to which his principles can be applied to some of Beethoven’s other structurally abnormal compositions, the mature two-movement piano sonatas (Opp. 54, 78, 90, and 111) and the eleven bagatelles, Op. 119. Ultimately, I find that while Tovey’s concepts are helpful, they do not yield equally fruitful results when applied to several types of pieces.

Name thesis:degree_name

M.Mus.

Level thesis:degree_level

Thesis

Discipline thesis:degree_discipline

Music

Grantor

University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign

Year dc:date

2011

Author dc:creator

• Warner, Michael A.

Contributors dc:contributor

• Kinderman, William A.

• Ludwig van Beethoven
• Beethoven
• Donald Francis Tovey
• Tovey
• bagatelle
• bagatelles
• piano
• sonata
• sonatas
• piano sonatas
• music
• classical music
• quartet
• quartets
• string quartet
• string quartets
• Op. 119
• Op. 131
• Op. 111
• Op. 90
• Op. 78
• Op. 54
• unity

Statement dc:rights

• Copyright 2010 Michael A. Warner

Language dc:language

en

Handle dc:identifier

http://hdl.handle.net/2142/18403

OAI identifier oai:identifier

oai:www.ideals.illinois.edu:2142/18403