The Process of Team Selection in Children's Self-Directed and Adult-Directed Games (Play, Socialization)

The study explored the way in which children selected their teams in their playground games and, as a means of contrast, the same process was examined in the formal setting of the physical education class. A qualitative research strategy employing a naturalistic mode of inquiry was adopted. Observation and interviews were the primary means of gathering information with a brief questionnaire providing supplementary data. The fieldwork was undertaken in one elementary school over a period of fourteen weeks and focused specifically on team games played by boys in grades three to six. The major findings were that, in the playground, the team selection process was an intricate mechanism by which children established and maintained 'fair' teams. Children were most particular about who got to be captains, the order of selection, and who could and could not play. The main criterion influencing the selection of captains, and of teams, was athletic ability with friendship as an interrelated factor. In physical education classes teachers generally chose the teams themselves most often using a system of counting by number. They were reluctant to involve the children in the process of team selection because of a concern about the time that would be consumed, and because they did not want to see individual children constantly chosen last by their peers. Overall, the study revealed a number of qualitative differences between the games children organize for themselves and those organized for them by adults. In the playground the game was a negotiated process, one in which the children were in control and where cooperation and accommodation were essential to the continuance of the game. It is argued that such spontaneous games offer children unique social experiences not available in adult-directed settings. In the formal class setting, the authority of the teacher prevailed and the children were obliged to accept a subordinate and non-participant role. Teachers were preoccupied with keeping children active, maintaining order, and making maximum use of limited time. The point is made that the physical education class may be an appropriate setting in which to provide children with the opportunity for leadership roles and responsibility under adult guidance.

Name thesis:degree_name

Ph.D.

Level thesis:degree_level

Dissertation

Discipline thesis:degree_discipline

Physical Education

Grantor

University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign

Year dc:date

2014

Author dc:creator

• Evans, John Robert

• Education, Physical

Identifier

(UMI)AAI8600171

OAI identifier oai:identifier

oai:www.ideals.illinois.edu:2142/71877