Savage reds: US settler colonialism, anarchist scares, and anticommunism, 1840s-1920s
type: CreativeWork
description: "This dissertation is a study of the development of US domestic political repression, labor control, counterinsurgency, and anticommunism. ""The only good Indian is a dead Indian"" went General Sheridan's genocidal axiom. By the 1880s, US politicians, industrialists, and their media organs were using the words ""Indian"" and ""anarchist"" in the heinous phrase interchangeably. This application of the ""frontier"" language of Indian-killing to internal political repression reflected a larger process in which colonialism was turning inward. This dissertation focuses on the period in which anticommunism/anti-anarchism became explicit in US culture, politics, and policy. It argues that there is a direct relationship between the United States' outwardly facing so-called ""Indian Wars"" on the ""frontier"" to class war within the metropole. The former structured the latter and both were part of the same project of capitalist domination. What historians refer to as the First Red Scare was preceded by over half a century of red scares. Those earlier red scares played out directly within the larger context of US ""frontier"" militarization and war. Internal repression was colonialism turned inward: meaning the tactics, weapons, mythology, and ideology the state wielded to control the ""foreign,"" migrant, multi-racial, multi-lingual, multi-ethnic urban ""rabble"" and extinguish proletarian insurgency were developed and refined in the ""Indian wars"" and other outward imperialist invasions and occupations. This is not to say that anarchists became the ""new Indians,"" as the US war against Indigenous peoples, and Indigenous resistance, never ceased, continuing unabated into the present. It is to say that settler colonialism and imperialism were so formative to US institutions that they structured internal political repression and internal proletarian control. The culture, ideology, and policies of anti-anarchism/anticommunism, grew from, were shaped by, and overlapped with th…
abstract: "This dissertation is a study of the development of US domestic political repression, labor control, counterinsurgency, and anticommunism. ""The only good Indian is a dead Indian"" went General Sheridan's genocidal axiom. By the 1880s, US politicians, industrialists, and their media organs were using the words ""Indian"" and ""anarchist"" in the heinous phrase interchangeably. This application of the ""frontier"" language of Indian-killing to internal political repression reflected a larger process in which colonialism was turning inward. This dissertation focuses on the period in which anticommunism/anti-anarchism became explicit in US culture, politics, and policy. It argues that there is a direct relationship between the United States' outwardly facing so-called ""Indian Wars"" on the ""frontier"" to class war within the metropole. The former structured the latter and both were part of the same project of capitalist domination. What historians refer to as the First Red Scare was preceded by over half a century of red scares. Those earlier red scares played out directly within the larger context of US ""frontier"" militarization and war. Internal repression was colonialism turned inward: meaning the tactics, weapons, mythology, and ideology the state wielded to control the ""foreign,"" migrant, multi-racial, multi-lingual, multi-ethnic urban ""rabble"" and extinguish proletarian insurgency were developed and refined in the ""Indian wars"" and other outward imperialist invasions and occupations. This is not to say that anarchists became the ""new Indians,"" as the US war against Indigenous peoples, and Indigenous resistance, never ceased, continuing unabated into the present. It is to say that settler colonialism and imperialism were so formative to US institutions that they structured internal political repression and internal proletarian control. The culture, ideology, and policies of anti-anarchism/anticommunism, grew from, were shaped by, and overlapped with th…
author: Khan, Tariq D.
language: en
keywords: Anarchism, Settler Colonialism
date published: 2021-09-17T02:34:43Z
date modified: 2026-07-22T22:24:52Z
provider: University of Illinois - Urbana-Champaign
publisher: Networked Digital Library of Theses and Dissertations
type: WebPage
source organization: University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign

PropertyValue
property ID: Handle
value: http://hdl.handle.net/2142/110722