{"id":{"repo_id":"uiuc","oai_identifier":"oai:www.ideals.illinois.edu:2142/101753"},"canonical_url":"https://search.dev.ndltd.org/etd/uiuc/oai:www.ideals.illinois.edu:2142/101753","repository":{"repo_id":"uiuc","name":"University of Illinois - Urbana-Champaign","base_url":"https://www.ideals.illinois.edu/oai-pmh"},"display":{"title":"A mother of light in the age of Enlightenment: Heterodoxy, interiority, and epistemology in eighteenth-century New Spain","abstract":"Colonial Mexico was a land steeped in Marian devotion, both to invocations brought from Europe and those arising locally. Into this Marian Zodiac of New Spain, Madre Santísima de la Luz entered in the early 18th century, and her devotion swiftly proliferated. The cult and image of this Most Holy Mother serve as an excellent case study to examine certain contentions in the age of Enlightenment, because just at the beginning of the period of contention, she burst into view in a blaze of light, proclaiming an alternate vision of a divine feminine, disciplined interiority, and knowledge as experience—alternate, that is, to the vision of enlightened reform and enlightened philosophy that was in process of taking root. In this dissertation, I examine these contentions of ideas and practices between what scholars have called traditional baroque devotion and both enlightened reform religiosity and the more radical enlightened philosophy. This examination is based on a study of the history, visual imagery, and iconography of Madre de la Luz; and of many texts, including devotionaries, treatises on mystical theology, artistic treatises, archival materials, council proceedings, and other resources. The areas of contention that I study are principally three: (1) heterodoxy; (2) interiority and exteriority; and (3) epistemology. In each of these areas, the image and cult of Madre de la Luz offer serious challenges to an orthodoxy that is established or is in process of being established. With regard to heterodoxy, they provide an alternate view to particular Catholic dogmas and religious attitudes. The challenge is made through the divine feminine redemptive force, blurring dogmatic options and tolerating ambiguity, that Madre represents. With regard to interiority and exteriority, they provide an alternate view to the newly developing orthodoxy of enlightened reform, with its preference for states of interiority intended to serve external useful ends and for the new bounded self. This challenge is made through a valuation of interiority for its own sake, tolerating a fluid self. With regard to epistemology, they provide an alternate view to the newly developing orthodoxy of the enlightened epistemology of disengaged study that claims dominance over an epistemology of direct experience. This challenge is made by proclaiming the value of the epistemology of experience, while appreciating the enlightened epistemology. Through the study of these contentions, the dissertation makes a number of claims as part of the extended scholarly project that contrasts ideas from the baroque and enlightened eras. It proposes that both the enlightened reformers of the late 18th century and modern scholars have misunderstood the roles of interior and exterior practices in both baroque Catholicism and enlightened reform Catholicism; thereby suggesting that we need to free ourselves from a reliance on enlightened reformers’ judgments, and attend to the teacher-practitioners of baroque religion themselves. Its more careful study of baroque devotional texts on Madre de la Luz (than any previous study), has identified intense interiorizing practices promoted within a context of exterior practices; thereby suggesting that we need to not only re-evaluate our understanding of the two Catholicisms, but also how we conceive of interiority, exteriority, and their interrelation. The dissertation gives voice to proponents of baroque interiorizing religion, a voice that has been hitherto poorly heard in the scholarly literature; and thus offers a more nuanced view of baroque interiorizing religious practice. It elaborates connections between iconography and devotional practice. It presents a comparative metaphorology of baroque and Enlightenment visual images, expanding the work of earlier scholars’ Enlightenment metaphorologies. It contrasts baroque epistemology of experience versus enlightened epistemology of disengaged study. It expands cases of particular doctrinal heterodoxies to express challenges against wider orthodoxies. Finally, as an undercurrent, it suggests first, the value of studying other religious systems (such as the religious philosophies of India) for understanding devotional religion in Mexico, and second, the importance of taking the researcher’s experience into account when doing historical research.","abstract_html":"Colonial Mexico was a land steeped in Marian devotion, both to invocations brought from Europe and those arising locally. Into this Marian Zodiac of New Spain, Madre Santísima de la Luz entered in the early 18th century, and her devotion swiftly proliferated. The cult and image of this Most Holy Mother serve as an excellent case study to examine certain contentions in the age of Enlightenment, because just at the beginning of the period of contention, she burst into view in a blaze of light, proclaiming an alternate vision of a divine feminine, disciplined interiority, and knowledge as experience—alternate, that is, to the vision of enlightened reform and enlightened philosophy that was in process of taking root. In this dissertation, I examine these contentions of ideas and practices between what scholars have called traditional baroque devotion and both enlightened reform religiosity and the more radical enlightened philosophy. This examination is based on a study of the history, visual imagery, and iconography of Madre de la Luz; and of many texts, including devotionaries, treatises on mystical theology, artistic treatises, archival materials, council proceedings, and other resources. The areas of contention that I study are principally three: (1) heterodoxy; (2) interiority and exteriority; and (3) epistemology. In each of these areas, the image and cult of Madre de la Luz offer serious challenges to an orthodoxy that is established or is in process of being established. With regard to heterodoxy, they provide an alternate view to particular Catholic dogmas and religious attitudes. The challenge is made through the divine feminine redemptive force, blurring dogmatic options and tolerating ambiguity, that Madre represents. With regard to interiority and exteriority, they provide an alternate view to the newly developing orthodoxy of enlightened reform, with its preference for states of interiority intended to serve external useful ends and for the new bounded self. This challenge is made through a valuation of interiority for its own sake, tolerating a fluid self. With regard to epistemology, they provide an alternate view to the newly developing orthodoxy of the enlightened epistemology of disengaged study that claims dominance over an epistemology of direct experience. This challenge is made by proclaiming the value of the epistemology of experience, while appreciating the enlightened epistemology. Through the study of these contentions, the dissertation makes a number of claims as part of the extended scholarly project that contrasts ideas from the baroque and enlightened eras. It proposes that both the enlightened reformers of the late 18th century and modern scholars have misunderstood the roles of interior and exterior practices in both baroque Catholicism and enlightened reform Catholicism; thereby suggesting that we need to free ourselves from a reliance on enlightened reformers’ judgments, and attend to the teacher-practitioners of baroque religion themselves. Its more careful study of baroque devotional texts on Madre de la Luz (than any previous study), has identified intense interiorizing practices promoted within a context of exterior practices; thereby suggesting that we need to not only re-evaluate our understanding of the two Catholicisms, but also how we conceive of interiority, exteriority, and their interrelation. The dissertation gives voice to proponents of baroque interiorizing religion, a voice that has been hitherto poorly heard in the scholarly literature; and thus offers a more nuanced view of baroque interiorizing religious practice. It elaborates connections between iconography and devotional practice. It presents a comparative metaphorology of baroque and Enlightenment visual images, expanding the work of earlier scholars’ Enlightenment metaphorologies. It contrasts baroque epistemology of experience versus enlightened epistemology of disengaged study. It expands cases of particular doctrinal heterodoxies to express challenges against wider orthodoxies. Finally, as an undercurrent, it suggests first, the value of studying other religious systems (such as the religious philosophies of India) for understanding devotional religion in Mexico, and second, the importance of taking the researcher’s experience into account when doing historical research.","abstract_has_math":false,"creators":["Cesarone, Bernard J."],"institution":"University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign","degree_name":"Ph.D.","degree_level":"Dissertation","degree_discipline":"Art History","degree_department":null,"school":null,"contributors":["Vázquez, Oscar","Rosenthal, Lisa","O’Brien, David","Meléndez, Mariselle"],"advisors":[],"committee_chairs":[],"committee_members":[],"year":2018,"date_issued":"2018-09-27T16:45:30Z","date_published":"2018-09-27T16:45:30Z","updated_at":"2026-07-22T22:24:40Z","subjects":["Spanish colonial art","Mexico","New Spain","Marian devotion","Marian cults","co-redemption","eighteenth century","Madre Santísima de la Luz","Most Holy Mother of Light","Enlightenment","Counter-Enlightenment","baroque","heterodoxy","heresy","interiority","exteriority","epistemology","divine feminine","religious discipline","enlightened Catholicism","enlightened reform","New Piety","iconography","devotionaries","mysticism","mystical theology","José María Genovese","Jesuits","censures","light","reason"],"languages":["en"],"rights":["Copyright 2018 Bernard J. Cesarone"],"rights_urls":[],"identifier_entries":[]},"links":{"outbound_url":"http://hdl.handle.net/2142/101753","outbound_label":"Handle","outbound_source":"dc:identifier"},"metadata_groups":[{"id":"people","label":"People","entries":[{"key":"dc:contributor","label":"Contributor","values":["Vázquez, Oscar","Rosenthal, Lisa","O’Brien, David","Meléndez, Mariselle"]},{"key":"dc:creator","label":"Author","values":["Cesarone, Bernard J."]}]},{"id":"academic_context","label":"Academic Context","entries":[{"key":"dc:date","label":"Dc Date","values":["2018-09-27T16:45:30Z","2024-09-27T05:00:00Z","2018-06-07","2018-08"]},{"key":"dc:type","label":"Dc Type","values":["text"]},{"key":"thesis:degree_discipline","label":"Discipline","values":["Art History"]},{"key":"thesis:degree_level","label":"Degree Level","values":["Dissertation"]},{"key":"thesis:degree_name","label":"Degree Name","values":["Ph.D."]},{"key":"thesis:institution_name","label":"Thesis Institution Name","values":["University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign"]}]},{"id":"subjects_keywords","label":"Subjects and Keywords","entries":[{"key":"dc:subject","label":"Dc Subject","values":["Spanish colonial art","Mexico","New Spain","Marian devotion","Marian cults","co-redemption","eighteenth century","Madre Santísima de la Luz","Most Holy Mother of Light","Enlightenment","Counter-Enlightenment","baroque","heterodoxy","heresy","interiority","exteriority","epistemology","divine feminine","religious discipline","enlightened Catholicism","enlightened reform","New Piety","iconography","devotionaries","mysticism","mystical theology","José María Genovese","Jesuits","censures","light","reason"]}]},{"id":"language_rights","label":"Language and Rights","entries":[{"key":"dc:language","label":"Dc Language","values":["en"]},{"key":"dc:rights","label":"Dc Rights","values":["Copyright 2018 Bernard J. Cesarone"]}]},{"id":"identifiers","label":"Identifiers","entries":[{"key":"dc:identifier","label":"Identifier","values":["http://hdl.handle.net/2142/101753"]}]},{"id":"additional","label":"Additional Metadata","entries":[{"key":"dc:description","label":"Description","values":["Colonial Mexico was a land steeped in Marian devotion, both to invocations brought from Europe and those arising locally. Into this Marian Zodiac of New Spain, Madre Santísima de la Luz entered in the early 18th century, and her devotion swiftly proliferated. The cult and image of this Most Holy Mother serve as an excellent case study to examine certain contentions in the age of Enlightenment, because just at the beginning of the period of contention, she burst into view in a blaze of light, proclaiming an alternate vision of a divine feminine, disciplined interiority, and knowledge as experience—alternate, that is, to the vision of enlightened reform and enlightened philosophy that was in process of taking root. In this dissertation, I examine these contentions of ideas and practices between what scholars have called traditional baroque devotion and both enlightened reform religiosity and the more radical enlightened philosophy. This examination is based on a study of the history, visual imagery, and iconography of Madre de la Luz; and of many texts, including devotionaries, treatises on mystical theology, artistic treatises, archival materials, council proceedings, and other resources. The areas of contention that I study are principally three: (1) heterodoxy; (2) interiority and exteriority; and (3) epistemology. In each of these areas, the image and cult of Madre de la Luz offer serious challenges to an orthodoxy that is established or is in process of being established. With regard to heterodoxy, they provide an alternate view to particular Catholic dogmas and religious attitudes. The challenge is made through the divine feminine redemptive force, blurring dogmatic options and tolerating ambiguity, that Madre represents. With regard to interiority and exteriority, they provide an alternate view to the newly developing orthodoxy of enlightened reform, with its preference for states of interiority intended to serve external useful ends and for the new bounded self. This challenge is made through a valuation of interiority for its own sake, tolerating a fluid self. With regard to epistemology, they provide an alternate view to the newly developing orthodoxy of the enlightened epistemology of disengaged study that claims dominance over an epistemology of direct experience. This challenge is made by proclaiming the value of the epistemology of experience, while appreciating the enlightened epistemology. Through the study of these contentions, the dissertation makes a number of claims as part of the extended scholarly project that contrasts ideas from the baroque and enlightened eras. It proposes that both the enlightened reformers of the late 18th century and modern scholars have misunderstood the roles of interior and exterior practices in both baroque Catholicism and enlightened reform Catholicism; thereby suggesting that we need to free ourselves from a reliance on enlightened reformers’ judgments, and attend to the teacher-practitioners of baroque religion themselves. Its more careful study of baroque devotional texts on Madre de la Luz (than any previous study), has identified intense interiorizing practices promoted within a context of exterior practices; thereby suggesting that we need to not only re-evaluate our understanding of the two Catholicisms, but also how we conceive of interiority, exteriority, and their interrelation. The dissertation gives voice to proponents of baroque interiorizing religion, a voice that has been hitherto poorly heard in the scholarly literature; and thus offers a more nuanced view of baroque interiorizing religious practice. It elaborates connections between iconography and devotional practice. It presents a comparative metaphorology of baroque and Enlightenment visual images, expanding the work of earlier scholars’ Enlightenment metaphorologies. It contrasts baroque epistemology of experience versus enlightened epistemology of disengaged study. It expands cases of particular doctrinal heterodoxies to express challenges against wider orthodoxies. Finally, as an undercurrent, it suggests first, the value of studying other religious systems (such as the religious philosophies of India) for understanding devotional religion in Mexico, and second, the importance of taking the researcher’s experience into account when doing historical research.","Submission published under a 24 month embargo labeled 'Closed Access', the embargo will last until 2020-08-01","The student, Bernard Cesarone, accepted the attached license on 2018-06-07 at 16:17.","The student, Bernard Cesarone, submitted this Dissertation for approval on 2018-06-07 at 16:53.","This Dissertation was approved for publication on 2018-06-07 at 18:20.","DSpace SAF Submission Ingestion Package generated from Vireo submission #12618 on 2018-09-27 at 11:33:05","Made available in DSpace on 2018-09-27T16:45:30Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 3 CESARONE-DISSERTATION-2018.pdf: 19593040 bytes, checksum: 9d3f88615337ab232930cd0c7273ef43 (MD5) LICENSE.txt: 4213 bytes, checksum: c2cd63ea215b570544288354e3a37883 (MD5) PROQUEST_LICENSE.txt: 4559 bytes, checksum: 83b5bb4d12a289af92e593ca1022a1f2 (MD5) Previous issue date: 2018-06-07","Embargo set by: Seth Robbins for item 107853 Lift date: 2020-09-27T16:45:39Z Reason: Author requested closed access (OA after 2yrs) in Vireo ETD system","Embargo set by: Seth Robbins for item 107853 Lift date: 2020-09-27T16:47:41Z Reason: Author requested closed access (OA after 2yrs) in Vireo ETD system","Limited Restriction set for Item 107853 on 2020-07-02T19:32:59Z with date 2022-09-27 by lac7@illinois.edu.","Limited Restriction set for Item 107853 on 2020-07-02T19:33:06Z with date 2022-09-27 by lac7@illinois.edu.","Limited Restriction set for Item 107853 on 2020-07-02T19:33:40Z with date 2022-09-27 by lac7@illinois.edu.","Limited Restriction set for Item 107853 on 2020-07-02T19:34:21Z with date 2022-09-27 by lac7@illinois.edu.","Limited Restriction set for Item 107853 on 2020-07-02T19:42:13Z with date 2024-09-27 by lac7@illinois.edu.","Limited Restriction set for Item 107853 on 2020-07-02T19:42:18Z with date 2024-09-27 by lac7@illinois.edu.","Author requested closed access (OA after 2yrs) in Vireo ETD system; patron requested extension, effective 07-02-2020","Limited"]},{"key":"dc:format","label":"Dc Format","values":["application/pdf"]},{"key":"dc:title","label":"Title","values":["A mother of light in the age of Enlightenment: Heterodoxy, interiority, and epistemology in eighteenth-century New Spain"]}]}],"canonical_facts":{"dc:contributor":["Vázquez, Oscar","Rosenthal, Lisa","O’Brien, David","Meléndez, Mariselle"],"dc:creator":["Cesarone, Bernard J."],"dc:date":["2018-09-27T16:45:30Z","2024-09-27T05:00:00Z","2018-06-07","2018-08"],"dc:description":["Colonial Mexico was a land steeped in Marian devotion, both to invocations brought from Europe and those arising locally. Into this Marian Zodiac of New Spain, Madre Santísima de la Luz entered in the early 18th century, and her devotion swiftly proliferated. The cult and image of this Most Holy Mother serve as an excellent case study to examine certain contentions in the age of Enlightenment, because just at the beginning of the period of contention, she burst into view in a blaze of light, proclaiming an alternate vision of a divine feminine, disciplined interiority, and knowledge as experience—alternate, that is, to the vision of enlightened reform and enlightened philosophy that was in process of taking root. In this dissertation, I examine these contentions of ideas and practices between what scholars have called traditional baroque devotion and both enlightened reform religiosity and the more radical enlightened philosophy. This examination is based on a study of the history, visual imagery, and iconography of Madre de la Luz; and of many texts, including devotionaries, treatises on mystical theology, artistic treatises, archival materials, council proceedings, and other resources. The areas of contention that I study are principally three: (1) heterodoxy; (2) interiority and exteriority; and (3) epistemology. In each of these areas, the image and cult of Madre de la Luz offer serious challenges to an orthodoxy that is established or is in process of being established. With regard to heterodoxy, they provide an alternate view to particular Catholic dogmas and religious attitudes. The challenge is made through the divine feminine redemptive force, blurring dogmatic options and tolerating ambiguity, that Madre represents. With regard to interiority and exteriority, they provide an alternate view to the newly developing orthodoxy of enlightened reform, with its preference for states of interiority intended to serve external useful ends and for the new bounded self. This challenge is made through a valuation of interiority for its own sake, tolerating a fluid self. With regard to epistemology, they provide an alternate view to the newly developing orthodoxy of the enlightened epistemology of disengaged study that claims dominance over an epistemology of direct experience. This challenge is made by proclaiming the value of the epistemology of experience, while appreciating the enlightened epistemology. Through the study of these contentions, the dissertation makes a number of claims as part of the extended scholarly project that contrasts ideas from the baroque and enlightened eras. It proposes that both the enlightened reformers of the late 18th century and modern scholars have misunderstood the roles of interior and exterior practices in both baroque Catholicism and enlightened reform Catholicism; thereby suggesting that we need to free ourselves from a reliance on enlightened reformers’ judgments, and attend to the teacher-practitioners of baroque religion themselves. Its more careful study of baroque devotional texts on Madre de la Luz (than any previous study), has identified intense interiorizing practices promoted within a context of exterior practices; thereby suggesting that we need to not only re-evaluate our understanding of the two Catholicisms, but also how we conceive of interiority, exteriority, and their interrelation. The dissertation gives voice to proponents of baroque interiorizing religion, a voice that has been hitherto poorly heard in the scholarly literature; and thus offers a more nuanced view of baroque interiorizing religious practice. It elaborates connections between iconography and devotional practice. It presents a comparative metaphorology of baroque and Enlightenment visual images, expanding the work of earlier scholars’ Enlightenment metaphorologies. It contrasts baroque epistemology of experience versus enlightened epistemology of disengaged study. It expands cases of particular doctrinal heterodoxies to express challenges against wider orthodoxies. Finally, as an undercurrent, it suggests first, the value of studying other religious systems (such as the religious philosophies of India) for understanding devotional religion in Mexico, and second, the importance of taking the researcher’s experience into account when doing historical research.","Submission published under a 24 month embargo labeled 'Closed Access', the embargo will last until 2020-08-01","The student, Bernard Cesarone, accepted the attached license on 2018-06-07 at 16:17.","The student, Bernard Cesarone, submitted this Dissertation for approval on 2018-06-07 at 16:53.","This Dissertation was approved for publication on 2018-06-07 at 18:20.","DSpace SAF Submission Ingestion Package generated from Vireo submission #12618 on 2018-09-27 at 11:33:05","Made available in DSpace on 2018-09-27T16:45:30Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 3 CESARONE-DISSERTATION-2018.pdf: 19593040 bytes, checksum: 9d3f88615337ab232930cd0c7273ef43 (MD5) LICENSE.txt: 4213 bytes, checksum: c2cd63ea215b570544288354e3a37883 (MD5) PROQUEST_LICENSE.txt: 4559 bytes, checksum: 83b5bb4d12a289af92e593ca1022a1f2 (MD5) Previous issue date: 2018-06-07","Embargo set by: Seth Robbins for item 107853 Lift date: 2020-09-27T16:45:39Z Reason: Author requested closed access (OA after 2yrs) in Vireo ETD system","Embargo set by: Seth Robbins for item 107853 Lift date: 2020-09-27T16:47:41Z Reason: Author requested closed access (OA after 2yrs) in Vireo ETD system","Limited Restriction set for Item 107853 on 2020-07-02T19:32:59Z with date 2022-09-27 by lac7@illinois.edu.","Limited Restriction set for Item 107853 on 2020-07-02T19:33:06Z with date 2022-09-27 by lac7@illinois.edu.","Limited Restriction set for Item 107853 on 2020-07-02T19:33:40Z with date 2022-09-27 by lac7@illinois.edu.","Limited Restriction set for Item 107853 on 2020-07-02T19:34:21Z with date 2022-09-27 by lac7@illinois.edu.","Limited Restriction set for Item 107853 on 2020-07-02T19:42:13Z with date 2024-09-27 by lac7@illinois.edu.","Limited Restriction set for Item 107853 on 2020-07-02T19:42:18Z with date 2024-09-27 by lac7@illinois.edu.","Author requested closed access (OA after 2yrs) in Vireo ETD system; patron requested extension, effective 07-02-2020","Limited"],"dc:format":["application/pdf"],"dc:identifier":["http://hdl.handle.net/2142/101753"],"dc:language":["en"],"dc:rights":["Copyright 2018 Bernard J. Cesarone"],"dc:subject":["Spanish colonial art","Mexico","New Spain","Marian devotion","Marian cults","co-redemption","eighteenth century","Madre Santísima de la Luz","Most Holy Mother of Light","Enlightenment","Counter-Enlightenment","baroque","heterodoxy","heresy","interiority","exteriority","epistemology","divine feminine","religious discipline","enlightened Catholicism","enlightened reform","New Piety","iconography","devotionaries","mysticism","mystical theology","José María Genovese","Jesuits","censures","light","reason"],"dc:title":["A mother of light in the age of Enlightenment: Heterodoxy, interiority, and epistemology in eighteenth-century New Spain"],"dc:type":["text"],"thesis:degree_discipline":["Art History"],"thesis:degree_level":["Dissertation"],"thesis:degree_name":["Ph.D."],"thesis:institution_name":["University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign"]},"updated_at":"2026-07-22T22:24:40Z"}