Toward a Fuller Understanding of Weiner’s Attribution Theory: Unpacking the Relationship between Controllability and Responsibility
type: CreativeWork
description: Weiner's (1985) attribution-emotion-action framework has been effective in predicting helping behavior. The model posits that perceiving someone as controllable/responsible for a need or a problem is associated with decreased helping intention and behavior through increased anger and reduced sympathy. Although controllability and responsibility were initially considered synonyms, Weiner (1995) later theorized that perceived controllability is a predominant antecedent of perceived responsibility, and responsibility is the primary predictor of emotions and behaviors. Moreover, there are other predictors of responsibility and mitigators of the controllability-responsibility relationship. Despite these clear theoretical distinctions, in practice, controllability and responsibility are often used interchangeably. This is likely because regardless of which one is used to predict help-giving, the data are typically supportive of the framework. Even though using controllability and responsibility interchangeably is common, recent studies indicate that there might be reasons to reconsider this practice. By using controllability as a substitute for responsibility, rather than a central predictor, the other predictors of responsibility are more likely to be neglected. This would minimize the utility of the model as other predictors of responsibility have been revealed. For example, Wickens and colleagues (2011) found that perceived intentionality is another predictor of responsibility. Yao and Siegel also found that intentionality predicted responsibility, and did so over and above the influence of controllability. A second limitation of using controllability and responsibility interchangeably is that it minimizes attention on mitigating circumstances where controllability is more or less predictive of responsibility. Yao and Siegel (2023) found that the relationship between controllability and responsibility was significantly weaker among parents who considered their own chil…
abstract: Weiner's (1985) attribution-emotion-action framework has been effective in predicting helping behavior. The model posits that perceiving someone as controllable/responsible for a need or a problem is associated with decreased helping intention and behavior through increased anger and reduced sympathy. Although controllability and responsibility were initially considered synonyms, Weiner (1995) later theorized that perceived controllability is a predominant antecedent of perceived responsibility, and responsibility is the primary predictor of emotions and behaviors. Moreover, there are other predictors of responsibility and mitigators of the controllability-responsibility relationship. Despite these clear theoretical distinctions, in practice, controllability and responsibility are often used interchangeably. This is likely because regardless of which one is used to predict help-giving, the data are typically supportive of the framework. Even though using controllability and responsibility interchangeably is common, recent studies indicate that there might be reasons to reconsider this practice. By using controllability as a substitute for responsibility, rather than a central predictor, the other predictors of responsibility are more likely to be neglected. This would minimize the utility of the model as other predictors of responsibility have been revealed. For example, Wickens and colleagues (2011) found that perceived intentionality is another predictor of responsibility. Yao and Siegel also found that intentionality predicted responsibility, and did so over and above the influence of controllability. A second limitation of using controllability and responsibility interchangeably is that it minimizes attention on mitigating circumstances where controllability is more or less predictive of responsibility. Yao and Siegel (2023) found that the relationship between controllability and responsibility was significantly weaker among parents who considered their own chil…
author: Yao, Xiaohui
keywords: attributions, emotions, responsibility, self-blame, social support, Psychology
date published: 2023-01-01T08:00:00Z
date modified: 2026-07-24T01:40:36Z
provider: Claremont Graduate University
publisher: Networked Digital Library of Theses and Dissertations
type: WebPage
source organization: Claremont Graduate University